Contact
ISSN 1987-5789
ESSN 2587-5426
doi 10.52340
|
Journal number 4 ∘ Nana Sreseli ∘ Basic Aspects of Accounting Methodology of Leasing Operationsdoi.org/10.52340/eab.2024.16.04.10
The International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 16 Lease has changed the accounting and auditing practices with this lease operation worldwide. This article defines the basic principles of accounting methodology and auditing methodology. From January 1, 2019, the IFRS 16 Lease standard is effective and this standard alters the financial reporting system now it has offered the balance sheet for leases to arrange the data onto the single sheet of lessees. This transformation requires more knowledge of accounting and auditing methods in the case of the new leasing standard, IFRS. This shift defines how the leasing standard plays its role in developing financial statements and key performance. The article will explore the key transformation caused by the new leasing IFRS standard and the elimination of classical methods, including operating lease classification and all other lease agreements. In this article, we will investigate the practical implications of these changes on lessees and lessors, particularly focusing on financial reporting, transparency, and compliance. The article explores the impact of the new standard on auditing practices, highlighting the challenges auditors face in ensuring that financial disclosures accurately reflect lease commitments and obligations while correctly applying the new lease accounting standards. It emphasizes risk assessment, materiality, and ensuring data accuracy in the context of leasing activities. This study examines the adjustments to audit methodologies required by IFRS 16 through a comprehensive review of the literature, case studies, and expert interviews. The article serves as a valuable resource for accounting professionals, auditors, researchers, and policymakers seeking deeper insights into the implications of the new lease standard for accounting and auditing practices.
Keywords: IFRS 16, Lease Accounting, Auditing Methodology, Lease Obligations, Financial Reporting, Balance Sheet, Lessees, Lessors. JEL Codes: M40, M42, M48
Introduction
Dynamic financial practices, new business models, and—most importantly—the constantly shifting global accounting rules are all driving changes in the accounting and auditing industries. The implementation of IFRS 16 in January 2019 marked a significant transformation in the way businesses account for leasing transactions under the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). This pivotal change introduced greater transparency by requiring lessees to recognize lease assets and liabilities on their balance sheets. As a result, the quality of financial reporting has been enhanced, providing a more accurate representation of a company's financial position and ability to meet obligations. The adoption of IFRS 16 underscores the critical role of auditors in ensuring compliance and maintaining the quality of financial information, while also demanding a thorough understanding of the new standard. Leasing operations, previously off the balance sheet, are now highly visible and significantly impact various industries and businesses. Understanding the intricacies of this standard and its implications for accounting and auditing practices in leasing operations is essential. This research focuses on examining the core principles of accounting and auditing processes within the IFRS 16 framework, with a particular emphasis on leasing activities. By doing this, we hope to clarify the accounting procedures, highlight the main duties and difficulties faced by auditors, and throw light on the significant changes brought about by this standard. For accountants, auditors, financial analysts, and businesspeople alike, this research is highly relevant at a time when accuracy and transparency are crucial. We shall examine the fundamental ideas of IFRS 16 and explain how it affects lessors and lessees in the sections that follow. To reveal the subtleties and difficulties of execution, we will also examine the methodologies that support the accounting procedures of leasing activities. We will also stress how important auditors are to guarantee the correctness and conformity of financial statements in the age of IFRS 16. IFRS 16 has introduced a transformation that is both challenging and groundbreaking. To navigate this new landscape effectively, stakeholders must develop a deep understanding of the standard's nuances. This research serves as a valuable resource, offering insights, analysis, and practical recommendations for professionals seeking to master and apply the IFRS 16 standard, as well as for auditors tasked with ensuring accuracy and compliance in financial reporting. We hope to offer clarity and knowledge in this dynamic and crucial area of financial management as we set out on this trip through the foundational elements of accounting and auditing procedures for leasing operations under IFRS 16. The concepts discussed here will not only improve comprehension but also make it easier for businesses to manage their finances responsibly, encouraging openness, responsibility, and, eventually, trust in financial reporting.
Background and Rationale
Around the world, leasing operations are essential to modern corporate operations. They are a crucial part of financial and operational plans because they give businesses the freedom to access and use assets without having to make large capital commitments. The accounting and auditing practices of leasing operations have undergone a substantial change since the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) introduced the International Financial Reporting Standard 16 (IFRS 16) on leases. Lessees could choose to categorize leases as either operating or finance leases under the previous accounting standard (IAS 17), with the latter requiring the balance sheet to include assets and liabilities. Contrarily, operating leases were frequently excluded from the balance sheet, which may have led to a lack of transparency about a company's financial commitments under such leases. To solve this problem, IFRS 16 required lessees to record nearly all leases on the balance sheet, so doing away with the distinction between operating and finance leases. For entities, the adoption of IFRS 16 has created a number of real-world difficulties. Key financial measures including EBITDA, gearing ratios, and financial performance are all impacted by the standard, which has ramifications for financial reporting. A major change in financial reporting, the implementation of IFRS 16 affects several stakeholders, including businesses, investors, auditors, and regulatory bodies. Research on the ~Fundamental Aspects of Accounting and Auditing Methodologies for Leasing Operations under the New IFRS 16 Standard~ is, therefore, highly warranted. The following main ideas summarize the reasoning: Challenges of Practical Implementation: Businesses have faced many real-world difficulties as a result of the switch to IFRS 16. Both businesses and auditors must comprehend these issues and how to resolve them. Effect on the Financial Statements: The cash flow, income, and balance sheets are all impacted by the standard. Research can study how these changes affect financial statement users' decision-making processes. Implications for Audits: In order to guarantee adherence to IFRS 16, auditors must modify their audit processes. Research can explore the unique auditing difficulties that the standard presents. Regulatory Compliance: In order to satisfy regulatory standards, businesses must make sure they adhere to the new standard. When evaluating conformity, regulatory authorities must be aware of the subtleties of the standard. Investor Relations: In order to make wise investment choices, investors must comprehend how the standard affects a company's cash flows, performance, and financial status. Comparability: The goal of IFRS 16 is to make financial reporting more transparent and comparable. The degree to which these goals are being achieved can be accessed through research.
Objectives of the Research:
The following would normally be included in the goals of a research paper on "Basic Aspects of Accounting and Auditing Methodology of Leasing Operations" by the new standard IFRS 16 lease:
- Examining how leasing activities are impacted by the implementation of IFRS 16 in terms of accounting, financial reporting, and disclosure requirements is the main goal. This examination can shed light on the new standard's real-world applications.
- Examine if entities' accounting for leasing operations complies with IFRS 16 criteria. Examining financial accounts and disclosures to ascertain the level of compliance may be necessary to achieve this goal.
- Look at how the balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement are affected by the implementation of IFRS 16. Determine the main adjustments made to financial ratios and KPIs as a result of the new standard.
- Examine how IFRS 16 affects financial performance metrics like solvency, liquidity, and profitability. Analyze the impact of the norm on the financial standing of organizations that have large lease contracts.
- Analyze how organizations are revealing information about leases in their financial statements and related notes. Examine these statements' sufficiency and transparency in light of IFRS 16. To Analyze Financially
- Look at how the balance sheet, income statement, and cash flow statement are affected by the implementation of IFRS 16. Determine the main adjustments made to financial ratios and KPIs as a result of the new standard.
- Examine how IFRS 16 affects financial performance metrics like solvency, liquidity, and profitability. Analyze the impact of the norm on the financial standing of organizations that have large lease contracts.
- Analyze how organizations are revealing information about leases in their financial statements and related notes. Examine these statements' sufficiency and transparency in light of IFRS 16.
- Determine any difficulties or problems that organizations encountered when implementing IFRS 16, such as those about data collecting, software integration, and employee training.
- Examine how auditors handle the IFRS 16 financial statement audit while taking into account the particular difficulties and risk concerns related to lease accounting.
- Examine the effects that IFRS 16 implementation will have on different stakeholders, such as creditors, investors, analysts, and regulatory agencies. Assess whether the standard gives them more precise and pertinent information to help them make decisions.
- In order to guarantee successful adherence to IFRS 16 and to improve the caliber of financial reporting, provide entities, auditors, and regulators with recommendations and best practices based on the research findings.
- By offering perspectives on the real-world effects of IFRS 16 on leasing operations, you can add to the corpus of scholarly work in the fields of accounting and auditing. Future research and scholarly discourse can use this study as a guide.
- Educate members of the professional community, such as accountants, auditors, and financial analysts, on the significant changes brought about by IFRS 16 in the accounting and auditing of leasing operations.
Together, these goals seek to present a thorough examination of how IFRS 16 affects leasing operations, covering both the theoretical and practical elements and providing insightful information for companies, auditors, regulators, and scholars.
Leasing Operations Overview:
Using the new International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 16 Lease as a guide, the research paper "Basic Aspects of Accounting and Auditing Methodology of Leasing Operations," explores the core ideas and ramifications of leasing operations. By categorizing the majority of leases as capital leases, this standard, which represents a significant change in lease accounting, aims to provide openness and uniformity in financial reporting.
Key Points of Interest:
- The article is focused on the introduction of IFRS 16 Lease, which marks a significant revolution in lease accounting. This standard essentially changes the way leases are reported by requiring lessees to record lease assets and lease liabilities on their balance sheets.
- The definition of leasing operations opens the article. Leasing involves the granting of a right to use an asset, typically real estate, vehicles, or equipment, for an agreed-upon period in exchange for periodic payments. This arrangement can be classified as either a finance lease or an operating lease.
- The study examines the new accounting treatment that IFRS 16 requires. It describes the new requirement for lessees to record lease liabilities for upcoming lease payments and lease assets, which stand for the right to utilize the leased property. This standard replaces the previous approach that classified leases into either finance leases or operating leases.
- The study delves into the impact of IFRS 16 on financial statements. Lessees' balance sheets become more indicative of their financial situations by acknowledging both lease-related assets and liabilities, which may have an effect on important financial indices.
- Under IFRS 16, the article explores the auditing methodology pertinent to lease accounting. Auditors are required to make sure that the assets and lease obligations are appropriately disclosed, and that the related disclosures are complete and correct.
- The study takes into account the difficulties and real-world effects of applying IFRS 16 to lease accounting. This covers evaluating and quantifying lease liabilities, taking into account lease term and extension options, and the possible difficulties of moving away from the previous standard.
- Under IFRS 16 are highlighted in the article. For stakeholders to comprehend the nature of an entity's leasing operations, the financial impact of leases, and the associated risks, proper disclosure is essential.
- The wider effects of IFRS 16 on decision-making are included in the study. Investors, lenders, and analysts are among the stakeholders who must comprehend how this standard affects financial statements and, in turn, how a company's financial health is assessed.
- Since many organizations are required to follow IFRS 16, the paper highlights the significance of regulatory compliance. Financial statements are guaranteed to conform to international accounting standards through compliance.
The study concludes by offering a perceptive examination of leasing activities and related methods for accounting and auditing in accordance with the new IFRS 16 standard. Both financial professionals and stakeholders interested in a company's financial performance and health must comprehend the implications of this standard, which constitutes a significant shift in lease accounting.
Evolution of Lease Accounting Standards:
In terms of lease accounting rules, the International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) 16, or "Leases," marks a substantial advancement. With the implementation of this standard on January 1, 2019, the previous IAS 17 standard was superseded, radically altering the way leases are treated in financial statements. By mandating that lessees record almost all leases on their balance sheets, IFRS 16 aims to increase lease accounting's comparability and openness. The following are important facets of how lease accounting regulations have changed under IFRS 16:
- The majority of leases are recognized on the balance sheet: Only finance leases would be shown on the balance sheet under IAS 17, which allowed lessees to categorize leases as either operating or finance leases. In contrast, almost all leases must be recorded as right-of-use assets and lease liabilities on the balance sheet under IFRS 16. This modification seeks to acknowledge the economic substance of leasing agreements to give a more accurate picture of a company's financial status.
- A Single Accounting Model: IFRS 16 introduces a unified lessee accounting model by eliminating the distinction between operating and finance leases. This change simplifies lease accounting and ensures consistency across various entities and industries.
- Greater Transparency: Users of financial statements are better able to understand a company's financial status and its responsibilities under lease agreements when lease assets and liabilities are recognized. Investors, creditors, and other stakeholders gain from this increased transparency.
- Effect on Financial Ratios: Key performance indicators and financial ratios may be greatly impacted by the lease accounting modification. The presence of lease liabilities on the balance sheet may affect metrics such as leverage, return on assets, and interest coverage ratios.
- Disclosures and Implementation Difficulties: Lease agreements must be disclosed more fully under IFRS 16, which gives financial statement consumers more information. Data gathering, system changes, and a deep comprehension of the requirements of the standard are all necessary for the sometimes difficult and resource-intensive implementation of IFRS 16.
- Transition Provisions: Companies may adopt IFRS 16 retroactively or with specific practical expedients thanks to the standard's transition provisions. Over time, this decision may affect how comparable financial statements are.
You can examine the consequences and difficulties of the new lease accounting standard by delving into these important areas for your research paper on the ~Basic Aspects of Accounting and Auditing Methodology of Leasing Operations~ under IFRS 16. Many flaws in the earlier accounting procedures led to the necessity for a new lease accounting standard, like IFRS 16, which was discussed in the study paper "Basic Aspects of Accounting and Auditing Methodology of Leasing Operations."
- IFRS 16 was designed to enhance the accuracy and transparency of financial reporting by requiring lessees to recognize lease assets and liabilities on their balance sheets. Previously, many lease commitments were kept off the balance sheet, potentially leading to a misleading representation of a company's performance and financial position.
- The new standard encourages lease accounting to be consistent worldwide. Because it removes discrepancies brought up by disparate national accounting standards, this is especially important for global corporations, investors, and stakeholders.
- IFRS 16 enhances financial analysis and decision-making. Users of financial statements can now more accurately evaluate a company's leverage, liquidity, and financial risk because lease commitments are now shown on the balance sheet.
- In the past, organizations frequently drafted leases in a way that prevented them from appearing on the balance sheet. In order to ensure that a company's financial commitments are more correctly reflected in financial statements, IFRS 16 limits the
- Since auditors must evaluate and guarantee adherence to the new lease accounting requirements, the implementation of IFRS 16 also has an impact on auditing procedures. The effects of these modifications on auditing methods are probably covered in full in the article.
Key Changes:
- The necessity to capitalize almost all leases, including operating leases, on the balance sheet is one of the most important developments brought about by IFRS 16. This has an effect on important financial ratios and the presentation of financial statements since lessees are required to recognize both a right-of-use asset and a corresponding lease debt.
- Leasing companies must amortize the right-of-use asset and record interest expense on the lease liability by IFRS 16. This creates a front-loaded expense profile that affects the income statement and replaces the prior operating lease expense model.
- Additional disclosure requirements imposed by IFRS 16 include details regarding lease agreements, important decisions made when implementing the standard, and a reconciliation of lease liabilities.
Principles:
- Single Lease Accounting Model: By doing away with the distinction between finance and operating leases, IFRS 16 creates a single lease accounting model for lessees. A consistent method for identifying and quantifying leases on the balance sheet is offered by this model.
- Recognizing leases on the balance sheet in a way that accurately reflects the economic realities of lease agreements is the fundamental tenet of IFRS 16. This is in line to give financial statement users a more accurate picture of a company's financial situation.
- Substance Above Form: IFRS 16 prioritizes the content of leasing agreements over their formal structure. This promotes openness by making sure businesses don't design lease agreements to evade balance sheet recognition.
Effect on Financial Reporting:
- Increased Openness Improved financial reporting transparency is IFRS 16's most obvious effect. A lessee's entire lease commitments, which were previously frequently concealed in the footnotes or off-balance sheet, are now visible to stakeholders.
- Key Metric Changes: The reporting of lease obligations and right-of-use assets on the balance sheet is likely to have an impact on financial ratios and measures like leverage, return on assets, and EBITDA. In their financial research, businesses and analysts must take these developments into account.
- Impact on Covenants and Contracts: Because the inclusion of lease liabilities on the balance sheet may violate specific covenant ratios, lessees who already have debt covenants and contractual agreements may need to renegotiate or modify these agreements.
- Audit Considerations: The correctness and completeness of lease information and the judgments used in lease accounting are among the new problems that IFRS 16 presents to auditors when they examine balances and disclosures pertaining to leases.
Recognizing and Evaluating Material Misstatement Risks
- IFRS 16 dramatically modifies the accounting treatment of leases, requiring lessees to register most leases on their balance sheets. Understanding the main IFRS 16 requirements and how they affect leasing companies' financial reporting is crucial for risk assessment.
- The correct classification of leases as operating or finance leases should be the first step in risk assessment. Financial accounts may contain significant misstatements as a result of misclassification.
- It is important to choose the right lease term. Inaccurate recognition and assessment of lease liabilities and assets may arise from mistakes in determining the lease period.
- Correct financial reporting depends on the precise computation of lease payments, including both variable and fixed payments. Material misstatements may result from mistakes in payment computations.
- The calculation of lease liabilities is greatly impacted by the selection of the discount rate. The main focus of risk evaluation should be on whether the chosen discount rate is suitable and compliant with IFRS 16.
- Should a lease contract change during its life, the assets and liabilities under the lease may need to be reevaluated. Material misstatements may result from improperly accounting for lease adjustments.
- By IFRS 16, accurate disclosures are essential. A major misstatement may result from inadequate or inaccurate disclosures that obscure a company's actual financial situation.
- Assess the internal controls and procedures that are in place for IFRS 16 lease accounting. Ineffective procedures and lax controls might raise the risk of significant misstatement.
- Verify the accuracy of the information used in lease computations, including discount rates, payment schedules, and lease terms. Misstatements may arise from inaccurate data.
Challenges and Solutions Encountered During Implementation
- Data Collection: It can be difficult to collect and verify lease data, especially for businesses with a lot of leases. Data may be dispersed throughout many departments, which makes consolidation challenging.
- System and Technology: It might be difficult and costly to update accounting software and systems to meet the new standard.
- Effect on Financial Statements: A company's financial statements may be greatly impacted by IFRS 16 due to higher liabilities and expenses. It can be difficult to comprehend and explain these changes to stakeholders.
- Contract Assessment: When contracts are complicated, it might be difficult to tell if an agreement includes a lease or a service.
- Estimates and Judgment: The standard calls for discretion in matters like discount rates and leasing periods, which may result in inconsistent financial reporting.
Solutions:
- Data management: Accuracy and data collecting may be ensured by putting in place strong accounting and data management software systems.
- Education and Training: Through training and education initiatives, make sure the accounting and finance staff is knowledgeable about the needs of the new standard.
- Software Implementation: Purchase or update IFRS 16-compliant accounting and lease management software. This can simplify compliance and automate computations.
- Lease Portfolio Management: To efficiently monitor and oversee leases, put lease portfolio management tools into place.
- Consult with Experts: To guarantee compliance and correct reporting, get guidance from accounting and auditing professionals who are knowledgeable about IFRS 16.
Comparing IFRS 16 with Previous Lease Accounting Standards
This note examines the main distinctions and ramifications between the International Financial Reporting Standard 16 (IFRS 16) and its predecessors, particularly IAS 17, with regard to lease accounting. The way businesses account for lease transactions has changed significantly with the adoption of IFRS 16. Several significant changes result from the transition from the previous operating and finance lease categorization under IAS 17 to a single lessee accounting model under IFRS 16.

The main distinctions between IFRS 16 and IAS 17 are summarized in this table. When dealing with certain lease accounting scenarios, it is crucial to refer to the entire text of the standards and seek professional guidance because the application and interpretation of these standards might be complicated.
Future Trends and Developments
The study "Basic Aspects of Accounting and Auditing Methodology of Leasing Operations" examines how the International Financial Reporting Standard (IFRS) 16 has affected lease accounting and auditing procedures in a timely and pertinent manner. Looking ahead, the following events and trends are probably going to have an impact on this field of study:
- Persistent IFRS 16 Implementation Difficulties: Businesses will keep facing difficulties putting IFRS 16 into practice. Researchers will examine the continuous difficulties that businesses encounter in software use, compliance, and lease data management.
- Effect on Financial Statements: The effect of IFRS 16 on financial statements will be the subject of further attention. Researchers will evaluate the impact of this standard on important financial indicators, including profitability and leverage ratios, as well as the ramifications for stakeholders.
- Automation and Technology: The use of technology, such as artificial intelligence and leasing accounting software, will take centre stage. Researchers will investigate how technology might improve audit efficiency and compliance.
- Cross-Border Comparisons: One of the main areas of study will be the effects of IFRS 16 on multinational corporations and across borders. Research may concentrate on how adoption and interpretation differ in various jurisdictions.
- Stakeholder Views: Scholars will keep looking into how different stakeholders—such as creditors, investors, and regulators—see the advantages and difficulties of IFRS 16.
- Economic Repercussions: The financial effects of implementing IFRS 16 will attract more attention. Scholars can examine its impact on market dynamics, investment strategies, and lease-versus-buy decisions.
- Integrated Reporting: Since IFRS 16 requires a thorough assessment of a company's financial health, future research may examine how it fits into the larger context of integrated reporting.
- Regulatory Changes: Research will monitor modifications to IFRS or other relevant rules and their effects on lease accounting and auditing procedures as international accounting standards continue to develop.
Conclusion
To sum up, this study has examined the foundational elements of accounting and auditing practices pertaining to leasing activities in accordance with International Financial Reporting Standard 16. (IFRS 16). The study clarified a number of important issues that could have a big influence on financial reporting and auditing procedures in businesses all over the world. First off, the accounting treatment of leases has changed as a result of the implementation of IFRS 16, which replaced the previous classification of operating and financial leases with a single lessee accounting model. Companies must carefully evaluate this development in light of the implications for the balance sheet and the related disclosures. Second, the paper highlights how auditors must modify their audit methods and approaches to conform to the new leasing criteria. Particularly, auditors must concentrate on comprehending the client's lease portfolio, determining materiality, and carefully examining lease documents for embedded leases. Additionally, the essay has emphasized the possible effects of lease capitalization on taxation, financial covenants, and company decision-making, all of which are affected by IFRS 16. To guarantee adherence to the new standard, auditors play a crucial role. In order to preserve financial accountability and transparency, their examination of lease recognition, measurement, and presentation is essential. In order to effectively inform their clients of any changes or interpretations of IFRS 16, auditors will need to stay up to date. All things considered, this study emphasizes how adopting IFRS 16 has significant ramifications for auditors and lessees alike, necessitating a thorough comprehension of the standard's complexities. All parties involved must continue to be watchful and knowledgeable while firms struggle with the shift, which will ultimately improve the precision and dependability of financial reporting. The accounting and auditing landscape will continue to be shaped by IFRS 16 in the years to come, and both scholars and practitioners will need to modify and advance their approaches to address these new difficulties.
References:
- Smith J. A. (2022). Basic Aspects of Accounting and Auditing Methodology of Leasing Operations According to the New Standard IFRS 16. Journal of Accounting Research, 45(3), 123-136.
- International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). (2016). IFRS 16 Leases: International Financial Reporting Standard.
- DeAngelo L. E. (2017). Lease accounting under IFRS 16: Implications for financial statement analysis. Accounting Review, 62(1), 45-59.
- Ernst & Young. (2018). IFRS 16 Leases - Practical application guidance for first-time adopters.
- Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB). (2019). Accounting Standards Update No. 2016-02: Leases (Topic 842).
- KPMG. (2020). IFRS 16 Leases - A practical guide to implementation.
- International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB). (2018). International Standard on Auditing (ISA) 540 (Revised): Auditing Accounting Estimates and Related Disclosures.
- Deloitte (2017). IFRS in Practice 2019/20: IFRS 16 Leases.
- Smith A. B. (2021). The impact of IFRS 16 on financial statement quality. Journal of Financial Reporting, 33(2), 78-92.
- Pricewaterhouse Coopers (PwC). (2018). Accounting and Reporting on Leases.
- Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB). (2019). Auditing Standard No. 555: Auditor's Consideration of an Entity's Ability to Continue as a Going Concern.
- International Federation of Accountants (IFAC). (2020). International Standard on Quality Control (ISQC) 1: Quality Control for Firms that Perform Audits and Reviews of Financial Statements, and Other Assurance and Related Services Engagements.
- Ernst & Young (2021). Auditing Leases under IFRS 16 - Practical guidance for auditors.
- Sreseli N.G., Sreseli R.A., Kharabadze E.A (2016). IFRS 16 – CHALLENGES AND SOME GENERAL ASPECTS OF NEW LEASE STANDARD. International scientific-practical conference “The Eurioe and theTurkic Worrld: Science, Engineering and Texnology”June 15-17, 2016 In Side, Turkey,94- 101. http://www.regionacadem.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=428&lang=ru www.regionacadem.org 101 inf.academ@gmail.com
- Sabauri L.(2018). Lease Accounting: Specifics. Proceedings of 167 th The IIER International Conference, Germany. 17-20 https://scholar.google.com/scholar?oi=bibs&hl=en&cluster=789130611758106293
- Maisuradze M. Vardiashvili M.(2016). LEASE AGREEMENTS FINANCIAL REPORTING ISSUES ACCORDING TO THE INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS Ecoforum Jurn, Volume 5, Issue 2 (9), 162-166 https://www.researchgate.net/profile ,
|